Chapter 7 Concluding Remarks

This thesis presented magnetic characterisation results on four closely related materials. The first two discussed were the honeycomb and hyperhoneycomb polymorphs of Na2⁢PrO3. These have tricoordinated lattices of jeff=1/2, 4⁢f1 moments, which have attracted recent theoretical interest as candidate platforms to host Kitaev physics. In both cases, this is the first time that single-crystal samples of the material have been magnetically characterised.

The second two materials discussed were the isostructural honeycomb transition metal titanites CoTiO3and FeTiO3, investigating the recent proposal that easy-plane antiferromagnet CoTiO3displays in-plane anisotropy driven by bond-dependent exchange interactions and a quantum zero-point fluctuations mechanism. Using single crystal torque magnetometry, I directly observe a six-fold in-plane anisotropy in the ordered phase, with an energy scale comparable with the value predicted from inelastic neutron scattering. I contrast this with the easy-axis antiferromagnet FeTiO3, where I observe the same effect in the ordered phase. In both cases, single-ion anisotropy can be rejected as the origin of the effect, leaving quantum zero-point fluctuations driven by bond-dependent exchange interactions as the most likely origin.

Honeycomb α⁢-Na2⁢PrO3orders magnetically at 4.6 K into a canted antiferromagnetic structure, which has a clear fingerprint in the angular dependence of torque in three orthogonal crystal planes. I propose two minimal models which can stabilise this structure, one with XXZ Ising-like exchange interactions, and a second model with Heisenberg J and symmetric off-diagonal exchange Γ. In both cases, a symmetry-allowed unbalanced Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya interaction on the honeycomb bonds causes canting of the moments in the a⁢c plane. Using torque magnetometry, I directly observe a spin-flop transition at high magnetic field, consistent with both magnetic models, and find a peculiar non-monotonic field dependence of crossover between spin-flop and paramagnetic phases.

Hyperhoneycomb β⁢-Na2⁢PrO3orders at 5.2 K into a much more complex four sublattice non-collinear antiferromagnetic structure. I report temperature dependence of AC calorimetry and torque magnetometry consistent with a sharp transition to the magnetic structure observed in powder neutron diffraction. I explore a proposed minimal model which stabilises this structure consisting of Heisenberg J and symmetric off-diagonal exchange Γ on nearest-neighbour bonds. I show that this model predicts a spin-flop transition with a particular field orientation and use pulsed-field torque magnetometry to observe this spin-flop transition directly in β⁢-Na2⁢PrO3single crystals.

Between the two proposed minimal models for α⁢-Na2⁢PrO3, the model with XXZ interactions is arguably the simplest. However, given the evidence supporting a J⁢Γ⁢Γ′ model in the polymorph β⁢-Na2⁢PrO3, and the shared structural motifs between the two materials, it is worth considering if both materials may be described by very similar models of bond-dependent exchange interactions. Additionally, both materials were theoretically predicted to host strong bond-dependent Kitaev interactions, and in neither case is clear evidence of this seen. Understanding the origin of these interactions will be important to understanding the physics of cooperative magnetism in 4⁢f rare-earths.

To date, a huge amount of research effort has gone into investigating transition metal compounds as candidates for strong bond-dependent exchange in the search for experimental realisation of a Kitaev quantum spin liquid. This has been very successful in finding exotic magnetic phases of various types, however no conclusive evidence has been found for a true Kitaev-QSL. The results in this thesis show clear experimental evidence that magnetic rare-earths can also host strong bond-dependent exchange interactions, and provides further support that these may be fertile ground in the search for exotic magnetic phases driven by bond-dependent interactions.